It took in $198,955 last week, about three-fifths of the earnings potential at the tiny 753-seat Booth Theater.
Thurgood opened at the Booth Theatre on April 30, 2008.
In 1976, it would begin an 867 performance run on Broadway, at the Booth Theatre.
The play transferred to the Booth Theatre on 18 May 1942; it ran for a total of 657 performances.
Ames directed the productions himself at the Booth Theatre, which received critical praise.
That musical had a brief run at the Booth Theatre in February 2009.
The original production of the play opened at the Booth Theater on December 14, 1936, and played for 837 performances.
He returns next month to the Booth Theater.
The musical would run at the Booth Theatre for 124 performances.
The intimacy of the 760-seat Booth Theater helps in this.