Green also hit another spectacular second shot, using his driver from the fairway, at the the par-5 ninth hole.
Green hit the big shot of the day from a bunker at No. 8 and blasted the ball into the hole for a birdie 3.
When Green hit a 3-pointer with 2:12 to play, it was 60-60.
Holmes was open, and Green hit him with a short pass.
Green hit a post with less than a minute to play in overtime.
Green played with a shoulder injury in 2003 and hit 28 home runs in 157 games this year.
At the same time, Green came around from Collins's left and hit his arm.
Green had never hit more than 18 home runs in a season (major or minor leagues).
Green hit only two home runs, however, and was eliminated in the first round.
Green hit passes of 6, 11 and 16 yards and scrambled for 5 more.