Not only could you use the million bucks to pay those legal bills, but the prestige would also back off Starr's replacement, Robert Ray.

A week ago, Robert Ray reported late and his train left about five minutes behind schedule, then set out at 11:32.

A year ago, he said, he worked two nights a week with Robert Ray.

"He had everything going for him - everything," said Robert Ray, a 64-year-old retired concrete laborer.

Colleagues also say that Robert Ray was known to take a drink or two before climbing into his subway cab.

"I didn't think Robert Ray ought to get blamed for the whole thing, as far as timing was concerned," he said.

Ruby visits List's house at night to get her cousin away and is found there by Robert Ray.

Robert Ray, the manager of the bartending agency, said as he passed out the test booklets that it was hard to fail.

That proved to be just as painful for his father, Robert Ray.

"I love it," Robert Ray said about his son's account.