The vote was 149,573 to 82,043, according to unofficial returns.
Yesterday, she won more than 83 percent of the vote, according to unofficial returns.
Early unofficial returns showed near 80 percent of the voters favored the plan.
The unofficial returns had Liberal candidate winning with a majority of one vote.
According to unofficial returns, it went down 51 percent to 49 percent.
He lost Schuyler by 10 votes, according to unofficial returns.
The vote in final but unofficial returns was 57,803 in favor of the plan and 37,940 against.
She won the election with about 61 percent of the vote (in unofficial returns), making a runoff unnecessary.
The proposal was narrowly defeated, 128,580 to 142,318, according to unofficial returns.
Hudson won the runoff by a large margin, with more than 63 percent of the vote according to unofficial returns.