He ran the ball into the end zone for an apparent touchdown in 1988, but the play was nullified by a holding penalty.
With 1:28 left in the game, Columbia scored the apparent winning touchdown.
On his third play, he faked a pass and ran 11 yards, only to have the apparent touchdown wiped out by a holding penalty.
After the game, the Giants were upset over the penalty that wiped out Tillman's apparent touchdown.
He completed a pass down the sideline to Phil Silva for an apparent 79-yard touchdown on the first play.
This time, he returned it for an apparent touchdown.
The bouncing ball was scooped up by Vince Buck and run back 61 yards for an apparent touchdown.
Jim Turner picked up the loose ball after the second blocked punt and ran 35 yards for an apparent touchdown.
There was nothing close about today, not after the Jets ended their opening drive by botching an apparent touchdown.
Instead, Hughitt took the snap and ran 27 yards for an apparent touchdown.