Two other appeals courts have ruled that it did not.

But two other appeals courts have ruled the other way.

In 2008, the appeal to the Italian Council of State on 19 January 2010 ruled in favor of Fidenato.

Although Charter Communications initially lost this motion and was forced to turn over the identities of the requested customers, a later appeal ruled that the motion to quash should have been upheld.

Two other appeals courts have ruled otherwise.

In contrast to the Ninth Circuit, all the other federal appeals courts to have considered the question had ruled that a seniority system always wins.

In an important victory for patients, two federal appeals courts have ruled that poor people may sue state officials to compel them to provide benefits promised under the federal Medicaid law.

Two appeals courts have already ruled in favor of the insurance companies, but they continue to be challenged in related proceedings.

In 1875, the GWR decided it would no longer maintain the river, and an appeal to the Railway Commissioners in 1877 ruled that they were not obliged to do so.

In the first tests in court, two Federal appeals panels ruled unanimously last year that the act violated the free speech protections of the First Amendment.