Army threw only one pass while relying on its strong and quick running game in beating Colgate for the third time in a row.
Lehigh beat Colgate, 86-71, and Bucknell defeated Army, 74-55, to move into the semifinals.
St. John's relied on defense and superior athletic ability to beat Colgate, 69-53, before 6,008 fans at Alumni Hall.
Georgia Southern, now 12-0, advanced today by beating Colgate, 49-28.
Talley's explosive team needed three fourth-quarter touchdowns to beat Colgate last Saturday in a playoff opener, and now it faces a difficult defense.
L.I.U. dropped four straight before beating Colgate, 78-70, on Sunday.
On December 4, 2010, he won his 300th game when UNH beat Colgate, 65-60.
That could set up Army for an invitation in the Liberty Bowl if it beats Colgate next week.
Navy beat Colgate, 13-7, and Army beat Boston University 41-0.
They skated rings around Cornell in an 11-0 triumph and beat Colgate, 2-0, last weekend.