Georges Duboeuf denied wrongdoing, blaming human error and pointing out that none of the affected wine was released to consumers.
South African officials blamed human error.
He blamed human error and said that a review would be undertaken "to ensure such a failing is not repeated".
In a 133-page report, the department blamed "human error" for the emissions.
Music and TV mogul blames 'human error' for former criminal winning £1m jackpot on gameshow's opening night.
Churchdown Online appologised to viewers blaming a communication & technical error which had occurred.
The group blames "human error" for the calculation problem.
Owners of cruise liner blame human error.
Allegedly the preliminary report into the accident blames human error.
The company spokesman blamed "human error" and described the incident as "most unfortunate".