But he carried his bat for 123 on his second appearance.
He passed 1,000 runs in 1896 with 2 centuries including carrying his bat for 125 against Gloucestershire.
Hutton's form continued in the fourth Test as he carried his bat for the second time in six months.
Woodfull carried his bat in a record-breaking first Test defeat.
Collins had played less than seven hours' cricket, carrying his bat through his side's innings.
In the next year, he carried his bat for 79* out of 190 against the same opponents.
In doing so he became just the sixth person to carry his bat through the fourth innings of a test match.
Kadeer Ali carried his bat and made 55 not out in their all out total of 103.
He became the second Yorkshire player to carry his bat through an innings.
He is one of just six players in the first class history to carry his bat twice in the same match.