Eugene Dabney led Rutgers with 16 points and 12 rebounds.
Jeff Greer led Rutgers with 18 points, but he did not score in overtime.
In the first game of the season, against Connecticut, he led Rutgers to a 22-5 victory with 173 passing yards and one touchdown.
Mauri Horton shot 9 for 20 and led Rutgers with 23 points.
She led Rutgers to the team title for the second straight year.
Phillips made 11 of 16 shots to lead Rutgers with 28 points in 21 minutes.
Lumpkin led Rutgers with 16 points, including four 3-point field goals.
Newton led Rutgers with 18 points and was the only starter to sink a field-goal attempt.
Teel could start the rest of the season, leading Rutgers through a fairly soft schedule.
Despite his injury, he led Rutgers with six sacks on the season.