He said he had been too busy to do any inventing since the litigation began in 2001.
So when the litigation begins we can supply proof that Runcible was not ignorant of either the discoveries or their scientific value.
Justice Kania is the second judge to withdraw from the case on a conflict of interest issue since the litigation began nearly four years ago.
The litigation began almost immediately after the law was passed.
William had been called to the bar before the litigation began, but the change in the family's fortunes forced him to seek immediate remunerative employment.
Deborah Barno, a lawyer for the commission, said the re-employment offer came only after litigation began, and was too little, too late.
It applies only when litigation begins in state courts rather than the lower federal courts.
These concerns are less troubling in this context because the litigation begins in state court.
The litigation charging the city council with providing a subsidy via a tax has predictably begun.
This litigation began after the United States took over a laundry's facilities to do washing for the army.