Hansen had already missed one from 51 yards late in the third quarter.
He missed 2 of 3 from inside 40 yards and is now only 9 for 15 in that range.
Then on their next drive, Wilkins missed a field goal attempt from 44 yards.
Against Baltimore nine days ago, he missed an extra point and then a field goal attempt from 41 yards out.
Mills kicked himself in the 13th minute when he missed from two yards.
But he missed the field goal attempt from 31 yards and the game went into overtime.
He missed his first attempt from 50 yards but went on to make 8 consecutive field goals to finish out the year.
Shafer had a chance to win the game on the final play of regulation but missed from 40 yards.
Had he missed from 53 yards, the Giants would have taken possession at their own 43.
He missed the first field goal of his professional career in this game, from 58 yards.