On March 13, a three-judge panel affirmed the decision to dismiss the complaint.

After hearing arguments late in 1978, another Phillips-chaired panel affirmed Manos early the following year.

The panel then affirmed the trial court on the Petite claim.

Although the same argument was made by each man, one panel affirmed the son's conviction, while the other reversed the father's.

The panel unanimously affirmed the ruling of the Nebraska court on July 8, 2005.

The three-judge panel then affirmed the district court's ruling in a summary order, without opinion, on February 15, 2008.

In October, a federal appellate panel affirmed that Oregon could stop paying a guaranteed rate of 8 percent a year to participants with individual accounts.

The special panel unanimously affirmed the commission's ruling.

The panel would then affirm or dismiss the charges.

The panel affirmed the judgment of noninfringement, but on different grounds from the District Court.