The guy glanced at the perfectly ordinary-looking accomplices on either side of him, pulled a fistful of singles from the pocket of his sportscoat, and said, "Boilermakers."
Satan was a perfectly ordinary-looking middle-aged man in a conservative, dark red business suit.
He wasn't a monster, though, just a perfectly ordinary-looking man.
Now it had a companion in a blue suit, a perfectly ordinary-looking man, studiously not meeting my eye.
Leading off a road I'd been down dozens of times before: a new, perfectly ordinary-looking, perhaps somewhat seedy little street.
I strode down a perfectly ordinary-looking street, got almost to the end, then was suddenly right back where I'd started from.
Alberich watched in fascination until there was nothing to be seen but a perfectly ordinary-looking inn courtyard with the stables at the rear.
She found herself in a beige-walled room, a perfectly ordinary-looking place with straight surfaces and square corners.
"People look at his pictures and want to know why that perfectly ordinary-looking painting is so powerful," he said.
Before me stood a perfectly ordinary-looking man in his early 50's, his dark hair beginning to gray.