Scott also played for the Gentlemen of Sussex from 1860 to 1869.

He also played once for the Gentlemen of England in 1938 against the touring Australians.

He played for the Gentlemen against the Players on several occasions.

After 1854 he played in only two more first-class matches, both for the Gentlemen of the South in 1858.

Grace last played at Lord's for the Gentlemen in 1899 though he continued to represent the team at other venues until 1906.

Gilligan played in the next Test match, without much success, and for the Gentlemen at Lord's.

He also played for the Gentlemen of England against Cambridge University in 1907.

He played for the Gentlemen in the Gentlemen v Players series.

He also played numerous non first-class fixtures for the Gentlemen of Hampshire from 1857 to 1864.

A professional, he passed 1,000 runs in the 1923 season, and was selected to play for the Gentlemen in July of the same year.