While some upper-middle-class families rely on the public schools, many that can afford private-school education opt out.

The job requirements: an attractive appearance, impeccable grooming and, preferably, a private-school education.

She has put her children through college, she lives in the neighborhood, and she wanted to help children who could not afford a private-school education.

They work primarily to pay for a private-school education for their little sister Charity, who wants to have a successful career and marry a wealthy man.

When the parents threaten to sue the city, the Board of Education eventually awards them a private-school education, at public expense.

The new proposals would effectively give wealthier parents a tax-free option for helping finance a private-school education.

Another point Mr. Cantor seems to miss is the cost of a private-school education.

Even with one child in school and an upper-middle-class income, my parents would have had to make many concessions for a private-school education.

"I believe my kids are now getting the equivalent of a private-school education."

But will a private-school education necessarily create these extraordinary children?