The vote fell just short of the two-thirds majority needed for passage.
Clark's vote fell by 1,192 votes but he still had a comfortable majority with 5,188.
The votes in the committee generally fell along party lines.
The Liberal primary vote fell 11.08% compared to the previous year's general election.
The vote fell by 6.2 per cent, and the party has lost all momentum.
The Liberals lost 118 seats (leaving them with only 40) and their vote fell by over a million.
And indeed his own vote fell by just 36.
The 9-4 vote falls short of the 10 required for approval.
So, there was no reliable way of knowing how the votes would fall.
Her popular vote fell just enough to force a second count.